Understanding the real costs and benefits of each approach helps you make an informed decision that aligns with your situation, whether you're a junior doctor rotating between trusts, a consultant planning long-term, or a nurse protecting your pension.
"There's no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends on your tax bracket, how long you'll stay in your role, and whether you prioritise ownership or convenience. Each option serves different needs." – Steve Thornton, CEO, Motor Source
Here's what you need to know: salary sacrifice offers tax efficiency and bundled convenience; personal leasing provides flexibility without employer tie-ins; direct purchase through Motor Source delivers ownership with average £7,500 NHS discounts and complete finance freedom: PCP, HP, or your own bank.
Understanding Your Three Options
Let's break down what each option offers and who it suits best.
Option 1: Direct Purchase with NHS Discount
How it works: You buy a new car using Motor Source's NHS discount (average £7,500), financing through PCP, HP, or your own bank loan. The vehicle is yours from day one.
Key advantages:
- Own the vehicle outright or build equity
- No mileage restrictions
- Full pension protection, no reduction in pensionable income
- Complete finance flexibility, choose PCP, HP, or bank loan
- No job change penalties
- After payments end, drive cost-free (except maintenance/insurance)
Considerations:
- Higher upfront commitment with deposit requirements
- You're responsible for insurance, maintenance, and servicing separately
- Depreciation risk rests with you
- Best suited for those planning long-term ownership (5+ years)
Option 2: Salary Sacrifice
How it works: Your employer arranges a lease, deducting payments from your gross salary before tax. This reduces your taxable income, creating tax and NI savings. The package typically includes insurance, servicing, maintenance, tyres, and breakdown cover.
Key advantages:
- Tax-efficient for higher-rate taxpayers (40%+)
- All-inclusive monthly payment, no separate insurance or servicing costs
- No deposit required
- No credit checks
- Brand-new vehicle every 2-4 years
- Some schemes offer job loss protection
Considerations:
- Reduces pensionable income (potentially £45,000-£60,000 over 30 years)
- Early termination fees if you change jobs (£5,000-£15,000)
- Mileage restrictions with excess charges (8-12p per mile)
- Business mileage reimbursement drops from 45p to 7p per mile
- BIK tax increases annually
- You never own the vehicle
Option 3: Personal Leasing
How it works: You lease a vehicle directly from a leasing company with fixed monthly payments from your post-tax income. At the end of the term, you return the car.
Key advantages:
- No employer tie-in—full job mobility
- Lower monthly payments than buying
- Drive new cars regularly
- No depreciation concern
- Predictable costs during lease term
Considerations:
- Deposit required (typically 3-12 months of payments)
- You never own the vehicle
- Mileage restrictions with excess charges
- Insurance and maintenance are separate costs
- Early termination fees if circumstances change
- No tax efficiency, payments from post-tax income
Cost Comparison: Real Numbers
Here's how the costs compare over different timeframes.
3-Year Comparison
| Option | Total Cost | Your Asset | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Salary Sacrifice (40% taxpayer) | £10,600 | £0 | Higher earners wanting convenience |
| Personal Lease | £14,800 | £0 | Those prioritising job flexibility |
| Motor Source NHS Discount Purchase | £17,500* | £15,000 | Building long-term equity |
*Includes: Purchase + insurance + servicing + tyres
3-Year Insight: Salary sacrifice offers the lowest out-of-pocket cost for higher-rate taxpayers over 3 years. Personal leasing provides moderate costs with job flexibility. Direct purchase costs more initially but leaves you with a £15,000 asset—valuable if you're keeping the vehicle longer.
10-Year Perspective
| Option | 10-Year Cost | Asset Value |
|---|---|---|
| Salary Sacrifice (3 cycles) | £31,800 | £0 |
| Personal Lease (3 cycles) | £44,400 | £0 |
| Motor Source Purchase (5 years payments, 5 years free) | £23,500 | £8,000+ |
10-Year Insight: Long-term ownership significantly reduces total cost of motoring. After your finance is paid off (typically 5 years), you drive free while leasing continues indefinitely.
The Pension Consideration
For NHS staff on defined benefit pensions, salary sacrifice has an important consideration: it reduces your pensionable income.
Example: Band 6 nurse, £35,000 salary, £370/month sacrifice.
- Pensionable income: £35,000 → £30,560
- Annual employer contributions lost: £1,052
- Annual employee contributions lost: £435
- Potential 30-year impact: £44,610
When this matters: If you're early in your career with decades until retirement, the compounding effect is significant. If you're closer to retirement or already have substantial pension savings, the impact is less concerning.
Alternative: Direct purchase with NHS discount maintains full pensionable income while still providing significant savings through the discount itself.
"The pension impact is real, but it's one factor among many. For a consultant earning £100,000+ who's already maxed pension contributions, salary sacrifice can still make sense. For a younger nurse building long-term security, ownership might serve better." – Steve Thornton, CEO, Motor Source
Motor Source Finance Options: Maximum Flexibility
Unlike schemes that restrict your finance choices, Motor Source offers complete flexibility while applying the NHS discount.
Three Finance Options—You Choose
1. Personal Contract Purchase (PCP)
- Lower monthly payments
- Optional final balloon payment
- Flexibility to keep, return, or trade
- Typical: £250-£350/month with £15,000 final payment option
2. Hire Purchase (HP)
- Fixed monthly payments throughout
- Guaranteed ownership at end of term
- No balloon payment uncertainty
- Typical: £400-£500/month, yours after 5 years
3. Your Own Bank Finance
- Use your bank's personal loan
- Often lower interest rates
- Complete term flexibility
- Motor Source still applies NHS discount
"We don't restrict your finance. You can use your own money or your own bank loan, choose PCP, use HP - whatever suits you. We apply the NHS discount regardless. That's genuine flexibility." – Steve Thornton, CEO, Motor Source
NHS Discount Examples: Real Savings
Motor Source provides fleet pricing typically reserved for corporations. Here are actual examples:
| Vehicle | UK RRP | You Save | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Toyota C-HR Hatchback 1.8 Hybrid Icon 5dr CVT | £31,645.00 | £5,729.77 | £25,915.23 |
| Kia EV6 | £45,585 | £7,719 | £37,866 |
| VW Tiguan R-Line | £43,325 | £7,294 | £36,031 |
| Average Saving | £6,900+ |
These discounts apply whether you choose PCP, HP, or your own bank finance.
Role-Specific Recommendations
Junior Doctors (FY1-ST3)
Your situation: Rotating between trusts every 6-12 months.
Recommended: Motor Source PCP with lower monthly payments gives you flexibility without employer tie-ins. Personal lease is also viable. Salary sacrifice carries high termination risk given frequent trust changes.
Why: Job mobility is essential during training. Motor Source PCP or personal leasing without employer tie-ins protects you from termination fees while keeping payments affordable during rotation years.
Consultants
Your situation: Stable position, higher income (40%+ tax bracket).
Short-term preference (3-4 years): Salary sacrifice offers strong tax efficiency if you want new cars regularly and job stability is certain.
Long-term preference (5+ years): Motor Source NHS discount with HP builds equity. After 5 years, you own outright and drive free.
Middle ground: Motor Source PCP gives you new car flexibility every 3 years while building equity—best of both worlds.
Nurses (Band 5-7)
Your situation: 20% tax bracket, valuable NHS pension to protect.
Recommended: Motor Source NHS discount with HP. Maintains full pensionable income while building ownership.
Why: At 20% tax, salary sacrifice saves 32%—helpful but not dramatic enough to justify pension reduction over a 30-year career.
Allied Health / Admin Staff
Your situation: Lower-to-moderate income, long-term stable employment.
Recommended: Motor Source NHS discount on more affordable new models (£18k-£25k range) with HP or your own bank finance keeps monthly payments manageable while building ownership.
Why: Builds assets without overextending budget. Motor Source's fleet pricing makes new cars accessible at prices that work within your budget. Salary sacrifice may be limited by National Minimum Wage requirements at lower salaries.
The Mileage Factor
Annual mileage significantly impacts which option makes sense:
| Annual Mileage | Salary Sacrifice / Lease | Motor Source Purchase |
|---|---|---|
| 10,000 miles | Typically included | Unlimited |
| 15,000 miles | +£500-£750/year excess | Unlimited |
| 20,000 miles | +£1,000-£1,500/year excess | Unlimited |
If you drive over 12,000 miles annually: Ownership becomes significantly more cost-effective. Excess mileage charges add up quickly over a 3-year lease term.
Decision Framework: Five Key Questions
1. How long will you stay in your current role?
- Under 2 years: Personal lease (maximum flexibility)
- 2-5 years: Salary sacrifice or Motor Source PCP (depending on tax bracket)
- 5+ years: Motor Source HP (build equity)
2. What's your tax bracket?
- 20%: Salary sacrifice saves 32%—modest benefit
- 40%+: Salary sacrifice saves 48%—significant benefit (if pension impact acceptable)
3. How many miles do you drive annually?
- Under 10,000: All options viable
- 10,000-12,000: Calculate excess charges carefully
- Over 12,000: Ownership strongly favoured
4. How important is career flexibility?
- Essential (likely to change jobs): Avoid salary sacrifice
- Stable (confident in role): Salary sacrifice viable
- Uncertain: Personal lease or ownership
5. Do you want to own or rent?
- Build equity: Motor Source NHS discount
- Always drive new: Salary sacrifice or personal lease
- Flexibility: Motor Source PCP
Common Considerations
Understanding "Savings" Claims
Salary sacrifice providers advertise tax savings percentages. These are real—but remember the calculation is on the gross amount, and lease prices may be higher than equivalent personal leases to account for the tax benefit. Always compare the actual net monthly cost, not just the percentage saved.
Accurate Mileage Estimation
Underestimating annual mileage is common. Factor in commuting, weekend trips, family visits, and holidays. If you estimate 10,000 but drive 14,000, excess charges add £400-£600 annually—£1,200-£1,800 over 3 years.
Total Cost of Ownership
When comparing options, include everything: monthly payments, insurance, servicing, tyres, deposits, and potential excess mileage. Only then can you compare accurately.
Why Choose Motor Source
Motor Source specialises in helping NHS staff navigate these decisions with transparency and flexibility.
What we offer:
- Average £6,900+ NHS discount (up to 35% on selected models)
- Complete finance choice—PCP, HP, or your own bank
- Fleet pricing without fleet restrictions
- No mileage penalties
- No job change penalties
- Full pensionable income protection
- Transparent pricing and honest advice
"We don't push one solution. We show you the numbers for salary sacrifice, personal leasing, and ownership, then help you choose what's right for your situation. Sometimes salary sacrifice is best. Sometimes it's not. You decide." – Steve Thornton, CEO, Motor Source
Summary: Which Option Suits You?
Choose Salary Sacrifice if:
- You're a higher-rate taxpayer (40%+)
- You have stable, long-term employment with your current NHS trust
- You value all-inclusive convenience
- You want a new car every 2-4 years
- Pension impact is acceptable to you
Choose Personal Leasing if:
- You need maximum job flexibility
- You're rotating between employers
- You want predictable costs without employer tie-in
- You prefer not to own long-term
Choose Motor Source NHS Discount if:
- You're planning to keep the vehicle 5+ years
- You want to protect your pensionable income
- You drive high mileage (12,000+ annually)
- You value ownership and equity building
- You want finance flexibility (PCP, HP, or bank loan)
Important Information
Disclaimer: All prices, costs, and savings figures mentioned in this article are estimates for illustrative purposes only and are based on new vehicles available through Motor Source. Actual costs may vary depending on the specific vehicle, finance terms, insurance provider, maintenance requirements, and individual circumstances. The figures shown represent typical scenarios but should not be considered guaranteed amounts. NHS discount percentages and values are subject to change and may vary by vehicle model and manufacturer. For accurate, personalised quotes based on your specific requirements, please contact Motor Source directly on 01522 500 055.
Salary sacrifice and leasing costs are estimated based on typical schemes available to NHS staff as of February 2026. Motor Source purchase costs include estimated running expenses over the comparison period. Individual results will vary. Pension impact calculations are illustrative based on current NHS pension scheme rules.
```
